Time is money

#31: What does value mean to you?

The Last of Us series is never far from the headlines, and seems to generate controversy like few others (hey wait don't go, this isn't all about The Last of Us I promise!). But the uproar over the recent remake's £70 price tag has been loud even by Last of Us standards

Naughty Dog's new remake is undoubtedly a full-scale PS5 production, rebuilt from the ground up for the console and as complete a remake as you could hope for, according to Digital Foundry. But of course the game running underneath - the mechanics, the performances, the score and everything else - had already been made.

Sony argue the remake is a AAA production in every sense, and the results certainly reflect that, but should we really be paying £70 for an upgraded game that's only 9 years old and is still actually playable on the PS5? The majority of reviews say yes. But of course, many don't agree.

In my opinion price shouldn't be factored into a review. Not only because a game's price (and content) will vary dramatically over time as the review invariably remains static, but because each person’s financial situation and reasons for wanting a game is different. A good review should tell you everything you need to know about the game and give an informed opinion on the experience it offers. It’s up to the reader to determine whether that experience is worth the current asking price.

Those who have never played The Last of Us in its previous form are getting one of the best and most influential games of modern times in full PS5-sized glory for Sony's PS5-sized price tag. Those who have played it before will have to decide for themselves whether the upgraded visuals are worth buying the game again. Still, with so many games remade and remastered with minimal effort (a subject covered in The Week in Games previously), it's at least good to see one given the lavish attention the original deserves.

We often assign value based on a game’s length, and that's problematic. It’s £70, but it has a 60 hour campaign and an additional 100 hours of side missions - it must be worth the money, right?

But how much of that time is actually enjoyable? How much of that time actually stays with you?

Indie games by nature are smaller and usually quicker and cheaper to produce, and that is reflected in their asking price, but many of the best reviewed games of all time are indies lasting no more than a few hours. Those experiences are worth just as much to me as the longer ones.

Of course I'm not suggesting indie games should cost £70. Merely that the value of a game is completely dependent on the player. I know if I’d paid £70 for Journey and whichever Assassin’s Creed was around then that - looking back now - it wouldn't be Journey I'd felt I'd wasted my money (or time) on. For many, the opposite would be true.

When I look back at my favourite games I never think about how much they cost me. I think about how worthwhile the experience was at the time and how much of it stayed with me.

To the Moon (a 16 bit-styled narrative adventure from Freebird Games) is only about 4 hours long and it changed the way I think about video games and the stories they can tell. I played it over seven years ago and its scenes, characters, and achingly beautiful score have stayed in my thoughts ever since.

You can’t put a price on that.

-

I hope you enjoy the rest of the newsletter!

Take care

Jeff

NEWS

DEALS

More!

  • PS5: The Ultimate Game Guide

As an incentive to sign up to The Week in Games, new subscribers now receive a link to download my PS5: Ultimate Game Guide for free. As most readers signed up before this offer started, I'd just like to give anybody who wants one a chance to grab a copy.

If you do, simply reply to this email directly letting me know and I'll send you the link as soon as I can.

  • Heterotopias 009

The latest issue of the wonderful Heterotopias "game spaces & architecture zine" launches on Tuesday September 13th. It's been a long time coming, but if previous issues are anything to go by it'll be worth the wait. You can check them out here.

NEW RELEASES:

The Last of Us remake hit PS5 last week and caused as much of a stir as expected. But anyway, the game itself is a masterpiece, and the critical consensus for the remake's upgraded visuals was extremely positive.

Less controversy from Splatoon 3 of course, which is out now on Switch and which Eurogamer claims is the best Nintendo's spectacular series has been to date.

(PS5, Xbox Series X/S) – September 6

(PS5, Xbox Series X/S, Switch, PC) – September 6

(PS4, PS5) – September 6

(PC) – September 8

(PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X/S, PC) – September 8

(PS4, PS5, Xbox, Switch, PC) – September 9

(Switch) – September 9

UPCOMING RELEASES:

(PS4, PS5, Xbox, Switch, PC) – September 13

(iOS, Android) – September 13

XIII 

(Switch) – September 13

(Xbox, PC) – September 14

(Switch) – September 15

(PS5, Xbox Series X/S, PC) – September 15

(PS5, Xbox Series X/S) – September 15

(PS4, PS5, Xbox, PC) – September 15

(PS4, PS5, Xbox, Switch, PC) – September 15

GAME OF THE WEEK

A randomly selected game each week! Any and all games are eligible for selection regardless of age, platform, popularity, or otherwise.

This week, the honour goes to…

SoulCalibur (Arcade 1998, Dreamcast 1999)

The Dreamcast was home to some truly incredible games during its depressingly short lifespan, and Namco’s SoulCalibur is one of the very best.

A staggeringly pretty and accomplished game, SoulCalibur also featured something all-too-rare in the fighting genre; an expansive and genuinely worthwhile single player campaign.

RECOMMENDED READS

By Rebekah Valentine - IGN

Howard Scott Warshaw shares his perspective on the games industry’s transformation since his tumultuous stint at Atari.

By Sarah Spitz - Vice

Alicia Kostoglou wasn't even born when the first Tamagotchi was released, but she's become one of the most prolific collectors since.

By Alicia Haddick - The Verge

When games like Dragalia Lost shut down for good, what happens next?

More for your inbox!

The Sample - A brilliant discovery tool that sends you recommended newsletters and blogs to match your chosen topics.

Refind - Every day Refind sends up to 7 curated links from around the web based on topics of your choosing - including, of course, gaming.

(The Sample and Refind are part of a cross-promotion. Any clicks/sign-ups directly help The Week in Games to grow)

CROWDFUNDING CAMPAIGNS

Old School Gamer Magazine

Ryan Burger - Campaign ends September 14th

The next generation of retro gaming magazine - Adding more content, more History - more Style and more Subscribers!

Filmmakers Without Cameras: The Trilogy

Eryk Sawicki - Campaign ends September 14th

A journal filled with gorgeous art and thoughtful writing on film, video games, and roleplaying games.

World of Anterra

81monkeys - Campaign ends September 23rd

"Skyrim with pixel art." An innovative, open world RPG influenced by classic and modern games.

nofio wireless adapter for Valve Index

nofio - Campaign ends September 27th

Experience the wireless freedom of Valve Index without a cable to the PC.

RPG Stories

Brave Alice - Campaign ends October 1st

A 3D Virtual Tabletop featuring a massive World Builder and Rulesets for all kinds of TT RPGs.

Fusion Retro Books 2023 Annuals

Fusion Retro Books - Campaign ends October 7th

When 3 Annuals became 6 - time for a bumper Annual Xmas this year!

VM2: The Next-Gen VMU

Dreamware Enterprises - Campaign ends October 9th

The Next-Gen VMU for the Dreamcast with Micro-SD storage, upgraded LCD, embedded Battery and Micro-USB port.

Please support The Week in Games!

The Week in Games is a labour of love that remains possible thanks to the ongoing support of members such as BitBloggist, johnXprinter & Seán Lynch. If you enjoy it, please consider a paid membership from only £1 a month. Thank you.

Friends of The Week in Games!

From custom framed art and premium journals, to gaming sites, fellow newsletters and beyond, our friends share similar values, a passion for quality and a willingness to support others.

Please click the images below and show them some love!

...and that's it for this week!

I hope you enjoyed this issue of The Week in Games! I’d be delighted if you would consider forwarding this email to anybody you think may like it, or sharing on social media via the links below.

I'm always looking at ways to improve this newsletter, so if you have any comments, suggestions, or enquiries, please reply to this email directly, write to [email protected], or catch me on Twitter!

Thanks again, see you next week!